Genesis and De Niro's Persistence
The story of Raging Bull's creation begins not with director Martin Scorsese but with actor Robert De Niro. While preparing for 1973's Mean Streets, De Niro read Jake LaMotta's autobiography "Raging Bull: My Story" and became obsessed with bringing the boxer's story to the screen. He spent years trying to convince a reluctant Scorsese to direct the project.
The director's initial hesitation stemmed from his lack of interest in sports generally and boxing specifically. "I don't know anything about boxing," Scorsese reportedly told De Niro, "and I don't really like it that much." Additionally, Scorsese was exhausted after completing New York, New York (1977) and struggling with cocaine addiction and health problems that led to hospitalization.
The turning point came during this hospitalization, when De Niro visited Scorsese and finally convinced him that Raging Bull was fundamentally about character rather than sport. Scorsese later acknowledged that he eventually saw in LaMotta's self-destruction a mirror of his own addictive behavior, stating, "I couldn't understand Bob's obsession with it, until, finally, I went through a rough period, and I came out the other side, and I said, 'I'm going to make the movie.' And I made the movie really to save my own life."
De Niro's Legendary Transformation
Robert De Niro's physical transformation for Raging Bull has become legendary in acting lore, setting new standards for method commitment that few actors have matched since. To portray LaMotta during his prime fighting years, De Niro trained extensively with the real Jake LaMotta, who said the actor developed skills that would have made him competitive as a professional middleweight.
More famously, to portray the older, overweight LaMotta in the film's later scenes, De Niro gained approximately 60 pounds (27 kg), increasing his weight from 145 to 215 pounds. This weight gain was accomplished during a four-month filming hiatus specifically scheduled to allow De Niro's transformation. The actor traveled to Northern Italy and France, indulging in pasta and pastries to achieve the desired physical change. The dramatic weight fluctuation concerned the film's insurers and medical professionals, who warned De Niro about potential health consequences.
Beyond physical changes, De Niro absorbed LaMotta's mannerisms and speech patterns through extensive time spent with the ex-boxer. The real Jake LaMotta even coached De Niro through the fight scenes, which were choreographed in advance but executed with genuine physical intensity. This total immersion approach, while physically demanding, resulted in one of cinema's most convincing transformations and earned De Niro his second Academy Award.
Black and White in a Color Era
The decision to shoot Raging Bull in black and white was highly unusual for a major studio release in 1980, when color had been standard for decades. Scorsese and cinematographer Michael Chapman had both artistic and practical reasons for this choice. Artistically, the monochrome palette evoked both period boxing photography and classic fight films that Scorsese had studied. The black and white imagery also allowed for greater control of light and shadow to express Jake's psychological states.
From a practical standpoint, Scorsese was concerned about the longevity of color film stock at that time. He had witnessed how quickly Technicolor prints of older films had faded and feared his work would not be preserved properly in color. Additionally, the black and white photography solved the problem of depicting blood in the boxing scenes—the use of chocolate syrup (a technique dating back to Hitchcock's Psycho) was more convincing in monochrome than any fake blood would have been in color.
United Artists initially resisted the black and white decision, fearing commercial consequences. Producer Irwin Winkler supported Scorsese's artistic choice, convincing the studio that the distinctive look would be an asset rather than a liability. While the film's initial commercial performance was modest, its visual signature has become one of its most celebrated aspects, proving Scorsese's instinct correct in the long term.
Revolutionary Boxing Sequences
The fight sequences in Raging Bull revolutionized how combat is portrayed on screen. Rather than focusing on the spectacle of the sport, Scorsese approached each boxing match as an opportunity to reveal Jake's psychological state and advance the narrative. This meant developing distinct visual approaches for different fights, with some presented in fragments and others in excruciating detail.
To achieve the desired effects, Scorsese and Chapman created numerous technical innovations. They built a boxing ring slightly larger than regulation size to accommodate camera movements. They placed the camera directly inside the ring, sometimes attached to operators who moved with the fighters. They employed varying film speeds—overcranking for slow-motion effects during emotionally significant moments and undercranking to accelerate less important action.
The film's sound design was equally revolutionary. Scorsese and his team recorded over 14 different types of punching sounds, from dull thuds to sharp cracks, to represent different emotional qualities. They incorporated animal sounds and exaggerated ambient noises to create a surreal aural landscape. During key moments, they dropped out background sound entirely to create subjective focus. These innovations transformed boxing sequences from mere sports footage into expressionistic representations of Jake's inner experience.
Critical Reception and Legacy
Upon its release in December 1980, Raging Bull received mixed-to-positive reviews and modest commercial success. Some critics were put off by the film's unrelenting brutality and unsympathetic protagonist, while others immediately recognized its artistic achievements. The film grossed approximately $23 million against its $18 million budget—respectable but not spectacular returns.
The film's reputation grew rapidly in subsequent years. It received eight Academy Award nominations, with wins for De Niro (Best Actor) and Thelma Schoonmaker (Best Film Editing), though Scorsese lost Best Director to Robert Redford for Ordinary People—a decision now widely considered one of the Academy's most egregious oversights. By 1990, just ten years after its release, Raging Bull was selected for preservation in the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress.
Its critical standing continued to rise throughout the decades. In 2002, Cahiers du Cinéma named it the fourth best film ever made. In the 2012 Sight & Sound critics' poll—widely considered the most prestigious ranking of films—it placed #11 all-time, the highest position for any American film from the 1980s. Directors from Paul Thomas Anderson to Spike Lee have cited it as a profound influence, and its innovative approaches to biopic structure, sports portrayal, and character study continue to influence filmmakers across genres.